Honeoye/Livonia: At age 64, Paula passed peacefully on November 4, 2024, at Strong Memorial Hospital in Rochester, NY. She was born on June 20, 1960, also in Rochester, to the late Vincent W. Schuster Sr. and Jane E. Whalen Schuster. In addition to her parents, Paula was predeceased by her nephew, Mark J. Schuster Jr., and niece, Mischon Elizabeth Schuster.
Survived by siblings; Jim (Michelle) Schuster of TN, Mark (Margaret) Schuster of Sparta, Ann Price of TX, Michael Schuster of Hamlin, Vincent (Nancy) Schuster Jr. of OH, Matthew (Angel) Schuster of Mt. Morris, and David Schuster of TX; her aunts, Rose Joyce, Barbara Nowakowski, and Alice Ann Schuster; nieces and nephews; Jillian (Cris) Puig, Meghan (Dennis) Stanley, Morgan (Brian) Moore, Matthias (McKenzie) Schuster, Alysia (Eric) Amouzou, Matthew Price, Tanya (Mark) Messare, Kimberly Schuster, Kristina (Malik) Schuster-Thurman, Michael (Jailen) Schuster, Austin Schuster, and Vanessa (Jose) Salas; also survived by many great nieces & nephews, cousins, neighbors, and friends.
Paula loved her family and friends. She was fun, loving, and had a great sense of humor. She was also an animal lover, particularly fond of her dogs and cats. She enjoyed living on Honeoye Lake and loved her close relationships with her neighbors. Her favorite pastime was building and competing in demolition derbies at local fairs with Cory Herzog. Later in life, she enjoyed making the best pickles, sausage, and sauerkraut, growing flowers, gardening, birdwatching, and learning to sew. No matter the trials and tribulations she was dealt in life, she always managed a smile and a positive outlook.
Family and friends may call on Monday, November 18th, from 4-6pm at the Kevin W. Dougherty Funeral Home Inc., 21 Big Tree Street, Livonia, NY. Paula’s Funeral Mass will be held at 10:30am on Tuesday, November 19th, at St. Matthew Catholic Church, 6591 Richmond Mills Road, Rte 20A, Livonia, NY. Livestream at: www.facebook.com/stsmaryandmatthewfaithcommunity Burial will follow at St. Michael’s Cemetery, Livonia. In lieu of flowers memorial contributions may be made to the Mark J. Schuster Jr. Scholarship Fund, C/O Sparta Center Volunteer Fire Dept., 8374 Reeds Corners Road, Dansville, NY 14437 or the Richmond Fire Dept., PO Box 469, Honeoye, NY 14471 or any animal shelter of your choice. To send a condolence or share a memory please visit: www.doughertyfuneralhomes.com
To Matt & family I’m sorry for your loss of your sister Please accept my condolences from my family to yours. She’s going to be missed dearly.
Sending love and prayers from the Cahill’s, Tim, Lisa, Madeline and Reilly. Tim and I met Paula when Vince and Nancy first got married. We enjoyed spending time with the Schuster family on that great big gorgeous house in the middle of nowhere (or so it seemed). I recall lots of laughter, and good times… and probably the best Whimpies I’ve ever tasted. Paula will be greatly missed, and our hearts go out to her family.
Paula. My American cousin. My brothers and sisters and I were so lucky to be able to come down from Canada in the summers when we were kids and visit with the whole Schuster clan. Best summers ever! Paula, I will remember you for your great big kind heart and your wonderful spunk. God bless you and your family. Much much love.
I was very sorry to hear of Paula’s passing. Growing upon Big Tree St ,we all knew each other. My brothers used to go up to the farm & help with chores ,although I think it was mostly hanging out & riding bikes. We grow up & move on with.our lives, but still remember the neighborhood kids. My condolences to the Schuster family. ??
Very sad and very sorry that Paula passed away. I think I still see her at her local places she visits. She is missed by so many. She was loved by many. She will be remembered fondly by us all. We think she’s gone because she left, but she’s in the trees, she’s in the breeze, her footsteps on the ground, she’s here, she’s there, she’s all around. Rest dear sweet Paula. Your friend, Mary Jo”
So sorry to hear of Paula’s passing. We remember the great times we had at conesus lake,with Paula and the Wells family.
I am so sorry for the loss of Paula. My parents lived next door to her for years and we had a great relationship with her. It was so fun passing poems & brownies with the family! (IYKYK) My heart broke when I saw that she had passed. She will be sorely missed. Sending love, hugs, & prayers to all of you.
We are so sorry to hear of your family’s loss, sending all,hugs and prayers.
Paula made me pickles again which I’m still eating. Loved her and will miss seeing her at West’s!! Still enjoying her pickles! Thank you for being a good friend. Condolences to the family.
Paula was an angel…always had the right thing to say at every moment. Blessed to have known and worked with her. ??
Paula, I hadn’t seen you in years but every time I seen you, it was like I had just seen you the day before. You’re beautiful person and I loved you. I will not be able to be at your calling hours as I have to work, but please know that I am there in spirit. Love always, Lori.
Oh I am so sorry to hear this news. Paula was such a good friend and neighbor in our youth. We had many fun times riding horseback together. She will be missed by many.
Paula was a very warm happy person. She always had a smile on her face and loved Marks golf tournament riding around with the kids making sure everyone was having fun
I will miss you give Terri a hug for me maybe she can teach you to ride a horse love you Fly High Paula
Your friend Patti and JR